The Accio-Potter Network

PotterProfiles, Events Calendar, Media and Forums

We have seen throughout the books that house points are mostly awarded on the basis of correct answers in class, and we know that Ravenclaw is the house that is known for intelligence. Why doesn't Ravenclaw win the House Cup more often? Is it because Professor Dumbledore, as a Gryffindor, considered actual actions and bravery more important than books and knowledge and intelligence? The only answer that I can come up with to answer this question is: the professors at Hogwarts have been instructed to diversify the way they award points so that all houses have an equal shot at the House Cup. Reply with your thoughts.

Share

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Well, the teachers at Hogwarts do tend to show a lot of favoritism. When Slytherins messed up in Potions Snape usually just sneered at them but didn't deduct house points. And Harry's complained before that Snape didn't award points for Hermione's correct potions answers. So I guess the Ravenclaws would earn a lot of points in Charms (Flitwick's class) but I guess they'd be overpowered by all the points earned by the other houses. 'Tis a shame. :(

Reply to This

Hmm, I want to add to this, but it's late and I can't seem to put together a logical argument. Oh well, maybe later.

Reply to This

Reply to This

RSS

Visitors Online/Map



Shop

T-Shirts

The Accio-Potter Podcast

Loading feed

APWR

Loading feed

Badge

Loading…

Bulletin

Join us at Accio-Potter!
Visit our Jobs Page
Don't forget to sign out!





© 2009   Created by Webmaster Alex on Ning.   Create a Ning Network!

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!